| Year | Result |
| 1994 | Denver Broncos 34, Philadelphia Eagles 7 |
| 1993 | Buffalo Bills 34, Philadelphia Eagles 27 |
| 1992 | Buffalo Bills 23, San Francisco 49ers 21 |
| 1991 | San Francisco 49ers 31, Buffalo Bills 23 |
| 1990 | Philadelphia Eagles 24, Pittsburgh Steelers 20 |
| 1989 | Buffalo Bills 31, Detroit Lions 23 |
| 1988 | Buffalo Bills 20, Atlanta Falcons 17 |
| 1987 | Philadelphia Eagles 15, Buffalo Bills 12 |
| 1986 | Buffalo Bills 37, Carolina Panthers 34 |
| 1985 | Jacksonville Jaguars 28, Carolina Panthers 6 |
| 1984 | Detroit Lions 19, Baltimore Ravens 0 |
| 1983 | Philadelphia Eagles 38, Buffalo Bills 28 |
| 1982 | Baltimore Ravens 24, Philadelphia Eagles 20 |
| 1981 | Green Bay Packers 31, Cincinnati Bengals 17 |
| 1980 | Minnesota Vikings 24, Cincinnati Bengals 21 |
| 1979 | Kansas City Chiefs 34, Carolina Panthers 12 |
| 1978 | Cincinnati Bengals 38, Carolina Panthers 23 |
| 1977 | Baltimore Ravens 23, Dallas Cowboys 17 |
| 1976 | San Diego Chargers 21, Los Angeles Rams 13 |
| 1975 | Cleveland Browns 31, Dallas Cowboys 21 |
| 1974 | Green Bay Packers 30, New England Patriots 17 |
| 1973 | Green Bay Packers 26, Buffalo Bills 20 |
| 1972 | Houston Oilers 26, Detroit Lions 16 |
| 1971 | Cleveland Browns 31, New York Giants 27 |
| 1970 | Buffalo Bills 41, Dallas Cowboys 21 |